Short answer
Hire an SEO manager who can read Search Console, set priorities for a site they have never seen, and explain how they would track whether AI assistants and Google's AI Overviews cite a client. Avoid anyone who promises rankings or talks mainly about link volume.
What does an SEO manager do in an agency?
An SEO manager in an agency runs organic search work for several clients. They audit sites, set technical fixes for developers, plan content with writers, and work on links and mentions from other sites. They report traffic, rankings and leads, and explain changes to clients.
The job now also covers AI answers. Clients ask whether ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google's AI Overviews mention them and get the facts right. A strong SEO manager knows how structured data, clear page copy and third-party mentions affect that, and how to measure it.
How is the agency role different from a brand-side role?
In-house SEO managers go deep on one site and can push changes through their own developers. In an agency the SEO manager has to get changes made by each client's team, so writing clear tickets and explaining priority to non-specialists is a large part of the role.
Where to find candidates
- SEO leads and senior executives at digital and SEO agencies
- In-house SEO roles at publishers, marketplaces and D2C brands
- Content strategists with strong technical SEO skills
- Analytics specialists who have worked on organic search
What to put in the job description
Job description outline for an SEO manager
| Section | What to include |
|---|---|
| Clients | Number of client sites and their type: e-commerce, publisher, B2B, local |
| Technical | Audits, crawling, site speed, structured data, migrations |
| Content | Keyword and topic planning, briefs for writers, content updates |
| AI answers | Tracking and improving how AI assistants describe and cite clients |
| Tools | Google Search Console, Google Analytics 4, a crawler, and the keyword tools the agency licenses |
| Must have | Has run SEO for a client site with measurable organic growth they can explain |
Add the reporting line, the location and working pattern, and the notice period you can wait for. Ask for the notice period at the first call; it usually decides the start date.
How to test candidates
Give a public website in a category you serve. Ask for a prioritised list of ten fixes in two hours, with the reason for each and who would make it. Add one question: how would you check what AI assistants say about this business, and what would you change if they got a fact wrong?
What to look for in the test
| Check | Good sign | Warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| Prioritisation | Puts fixes in order of effect and effort | Lists every crawler warning as equally urgent |
| Technical depth | Explains indexing, canonical tags and structured data clearly | Repeats tool output without explanation |
| AI answers | Has a method to test and track AI mentions and accuracy | Has not looked at AI answers for clients |
| Communication | Writes fixes a developer can act on | Writes for other SEO specialists only |
Interview questions
- Walk me through an audit you ran. What did you fix first, and what happened?
- A client's organic traffic fell after a site migration. Where do you look first?
- How do you measure whether ChatGPT or Google AI Overviews mention a client?
- How do you decide whether to update an old page or write a new one?
- Tell me about a link-building approach you stopped using, and why.
- How do you explain an SEO priority to a client's developer who disagrees?
Hiring an SEO manager through VelivoHR
Intake happens on Day 0, once the Recruitment Services Agreement is signed: we agree the job description and the scoring rubric with you. The first shortlist reaches you within 24 hours, often within the hour. Every application is screened through Velivo7, our internal seven-agent process, and our HR team reviews each shortlist before you see it.
The fee is 8.33% of the hire's annual CTC for roles up to ₹50 lakh and 11.33% above, plus GST, with no retainer. Every placement carries a 90-day replacement guarantee. See pricing and how a search runs.

